Changelings review online

[Ghyle]

There is a short review of Changelings here:

http://www.sfreader.com/read_review.asp?book=920

Is it fair? Is it honest? What are your thoughts on the review?

[C_ris]

I agree with it completely.

[Bamy]

I do too...but I missed the sex change of the Track cats...

[C_ris]

The sex changed annoyed me constantly.

[Bamy]

Was it Coaxtl and Nanook or the little fuzzies?

[C_ris]

Coaxtl and Nanook.

[elfycat]

I'm not a fan of these two books. It's nice to catch up with some of the characters but it's all a bit flat somehow

[edith]

It was a bit flat- so was Maelstrom.
Very long in some places and cut short in others!

[C_ris]

Yup, definitely a let-down after the earlier books. :(

[Bamy]

Not read Maelstrom yet...but the first rwas a very easy read...nowhere near as meaty as the first three or the earlier books of other series.

[Bamy]

I find Acorna's Children to be very similar to the Petaybe twins book too...easy reads...though a little more meaty.

[Lady UnderWeyr]

I noticed the sex change and it annoyed me too. Nanook was supposed to be male and Coxtyl was female.

Maelstorm was cut way to short... it was going at a pretty good clip and then WHAM! Right into a brick wall... or off a cliff...

[Greenrider Tresa]

Very frustrating when the ending sneaks up before you expect it to!

[Pernita]

Definitely room for yet another book!
(just finished maelstrom)

Odd the way it just stopped and left those loose ends